Chapter 7 & Chapter 13 bankruptcy · Chandler, AZ · Serving people around the state Call or text Jeff: (480) 622-4987
Jeff Biddle Law, Bankruptcy Attorney

The Debting Game

Penny Lane is overwhelmed by debt. Help her quiz four very different bachelors, then pick her dream date. A parody, just for fun.

Penny Lane, a calico cat with a pink bow, sits in an orange egg chair holding three envelopes. Versace, the host, stands at right in a sparkly tuxedo with a microphone, under The Debting Game sign.
Four bachelors on bar stools, left to right: Lightning Wipeout in a backwards cap with a skateboard, Thurston Planwell in a cardigan with a briefcase, the twins Manny McDebt with a calculator and clipboard and Cutty McDebt in a patterned jacket, and Maximus Pluribus in a dark suit.
Pick a bachelor
Question: Pick a question to get started.
Penny Lane

Penny Lane

Our bachelorette

Pick a question, then pick a bachelor to hear his answer.

Versace, your host
VersaceWelcome to The Debting Game! Pick a question for Penny, then pick a bachelor to answer it.
Tonight's episode, in print

Every Question, Every Answer

Prefer reading to flirting? Here's everything all four bachelors said. General information only: the right option depends on your whole situation.

Meet the Bachelors

Bachelor #1: Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7)

Chapter 7 is the fast mover of the group: confident, decisive, and ready to wipe the slate clean in about four months. He doesn't ask you to pay anything back, and he's the quickest way to stop the calls and garnishments. He's honest about his baggage, though. He stays on your credit report for 10 years, and he's picky about who qualifies, since you have to pass the means test. If you want a fresh start and don't want to wait for it, he's your guy.

Bachelor #2: Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13)

Chapter 13 is the steady, dependable one who's looking for a real commitment of three to five years. He's the hero for anyone about to lose a house or car: he stops foreclosures and repossessions and lets you catch up over time. He's the only contestant who protects your cosigners, and he'll take you even if you earn too much for Chapter 7. He asks for a monthly payment and some patience, but at the end, whatever unsecured debt is left gets wiped out.

Bachelor #3: Manny McDebt & Cutty McDebt (Debt Management & Debt Settlement)

Contestant #3 is a pair of fraternal twins who grew up in the same house but couldn't be more different. Debt Management is the clean-cut nonprofit twin. He calls your creditors, gets your interest rates lowered, and has you pay back every penny in one monthly payment over three to five years. Debt Settlement is the smooth-talking bad boy. He promises to cut your debt in half if you stop paying your creditors and save up for lump-sum deals. Neither twin can stop a lawsuit or a garnishment, and both have a habit of losing people before the finish line.

Bachelor #4: Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan)

The Consolidation Loan is the polished, respectable one who looks perfect on paper. He rolls all your card balances into one fixed monthly payment, ideally at a lower interest rate, with no court, no trustee, and nobody finding out. But he's picky. He wants good credit and steady income, and he expects every penny back with interest. If you're already drowning, he's probably out of your league, and if you run your cards back up after him, you'll be worse off than before.

The Questions

1. Will this hurt my credit?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "I won't lie, I stay on your credit report for 10 years. But most people's scores start climbing within a year or two, and some see a bump right away because the debt is gone."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "I stay on your report for seven years, three fewer than Chapter 7. And lenders like that you paid something back."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "Barely. Your cards get closed, but on-time payments help you rebuild." Cutty (Settlement): "You'll stop paying creditors while you save up, so... yeah, it'll take a beating."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Only a small dip from the credit check. If you pay me on time and don't run your cards back up, your score can actually improve."

2. Can I keep my house and car?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "Usually, yes. Arizona protects up to $400,000 of home equity and $15,000 in a car, or $25,000 if you're disabled. If you're current on the payments and want to keep them, we can make it work."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "This is my specialty. I can stop a foreclosure or repossession and let you catch up on missed payments over three to five years. I can even lower some car loans to the car's value."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Both: "We only handle unsecured debt like cards and medical bills. Behind on your mortgage or car? We can't help you there."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "I only roll up unsecured debt like cards. But if I'm a home equity loan, your house becomes the collateral, so miss payments and you could lose it."

3. Will it stop the calls, lawsuits, and garnishments?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "The second you file, the automatic stay kicks in. Calls, lawsuits, and garnishments all stop. Consider me your bouncer."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Same automatic stay as Chapter 7, and it lasts my whole plan. Collectors have to go through me."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "The calls usually calm down." Cutty (Settlement): "Not really. We have no automatic stay, so creditors can still sue you and garnish your wages, and with me, that happens a lot."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Only because I pay off the old creditors. There's no automatic stay, and if you're already being sued, I probably won't approve you."

4. How much does this cost?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "The court filing fee is $338, plus a lawyer's fee. It's a one-time cost, not years of payments."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "The filing fee is $313, and most of my lawyer's fee can be paid through the plan, so you don't need it all up front."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "A small setup fee and about $25 to $50 a month." Cutty (Settlement): "I take 15% to 25% of whatever I settle. I can't charge you up front, but you'll be saving up for months while your creditors get angry. And honestly? Most people never finish. Government investigators found fewer than one in ten get all their debts settled, and even my own industry says it's under one in four. A lot of people end up paying fees, getting sued anyway, and filing bankruptcy after all."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Interest usually runs about 8% to 36% depending on your credit, plus a possible origination fee of up to about 10%. If your credit is shaky, I may not be cheaper than your cards."

5. How long does it take?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "About three to four months, from filing to discharge. I don't do long engagements."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Three to five years. I'm looking for something serious."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "Three to five years." Cutty (Settlement): "Two to four. If it works."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Usually two to seven years of fixed payments."

6. Will I have to pay it all back?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "Nope. Credit cards, medical bills, and personal loans are wiped out. You owe them nothing."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Not all of it. You pay what you can afford, based on your income, and whatever unsecured debt is left at the end is wiped out."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "Every penny, just at lower interest." Cutty (Settlement): "I can get you a discount, often around half, but creditors don't have to accept."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Every penny, plus interest. I just make it one payment."

7. Does it cover student loans, taxes, and medical bills?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "Medical bills, absolutely. Older income taxes sometimes, if they meet the timing rules. Student loans only if you prove undue hardship, but that's more doable than it used to be."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Medical bills, yes. Taxes I can spread over the plan with no new penalties, and older ones may be discharged. Student loans get paid alongside your other debts, but they survive unless you prove undue hardship."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Both: "Medical bills, yes. Federal student loans and taxes, no. Those have their own programs."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Medical bills and cards, yes. Federal student loans have their own consolidation program, and taxes need an IRS payment plan."

8. Will my spouse or a cosigner be affected?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "I protect you, not your cosigner, so they still owe the debt. Arizona's community property rules can protect some of your spouse's property from community debts, though."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "I'm the only one who protects cosigners. The codebtor stay keeps creditors off them while my plan is running."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "Your cosigner isn't protected." Cutty (Settlement): "And with me, creditors may go after them while you're skipping payments."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Only if they cosign for me. Then they're on the hook too."

9. Will my employer find out?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "Only if your wages are being garnished. Even then, a private employer can't fire you just for filing bankruptcy."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Sometimes. Your payment can come straight out of your paycheck, but a private employer still can't fire you just for filing."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "Not from me." Cutty (Settlement): "Not unless a creditor sues you and garnishes your wages. That's a real risk with me."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "No. I'm completely private."

10. Can I keep my retirement?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "Yes. 401(k)s, IRAs, and pensions are protected. Please don't drain them paying off credit cards first."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Yes, it stays protected, and you can usually keep contributing to it during the plan."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Cutty (Settlement): "Sure, we never touch it." Manny (Management): "But a lawsuit judgment doesn't care how much my brother loves you."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Yes. Just don't let anyone talk you into a 401(k) loan to pay off cards."

11. Can I buy a house or car afterward?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "A car loan, often within months. An FHA mortgage, about two years after discharge, and a conventional one, about four."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "Even during the plan, if the trustee or court approves. An FHA mortgage is possible after a year of on-time plan payments."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "It's easier after me than after him." Cutty (Settlement): "Lenders will still see those charged-off accounts."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "Usually, yes, as long as you make my payments on time."

12. Do I even qualify for this?

Bachelor #1, Lightning Wipeout (Chapter 7): "You have to pass the means test, which compares your income to Arizona's median. And you can't have gotten a Chapter 7 discharge in the last eight years."

Bachelor #2, Thurston Planwell (Chapter 13): "You need steady income and debts under the federal limits. I'm also your option if you earn too much for Chapter 7."

Bachelor #3, the McDebt twins: Manny (Management): "You need enough income to pay the whole balance at lower interest." Cutty (Settlement): "You need cash saved up for lump sums. Oh, and settled debt over $600 can be taxed as income, unless you were insolvent."

Bachelor #4, Maximus Pluribus (Consolidation Loan): "That's my catch. I want good credit, steady income, and a manageable debt-to-income ratio. If you're already drowning, I'm probably out of your league."

Want to know which one is really your match? Talk to Jeff or call 480-622-4987.

The Debting Game is a parody and isn't affiliated with any TV show. Nothing you pick here is stored or sent anywhere.