Car Accident Claims and Bankruptcy in Arizona: Car accidents, injury claims and lawsuits, before and during bankruptcy

It was a quiet night at Bankruptcy Cats HQ. I had just settled into my armchair when three cats curled up together and demanded a bedtime story. Athena brought her blanket. Versace brought his crown, which he insists on wearing to bed. Rocky brought a stack of law books, which he insists he isn't going to read.

"Story, please," said Athena.

"A story about me," said Versace. "Your Majesty is the star of every bedtime story. That is the rule."

A brown-and-white tabby with a collar tag sings in a little red convertible, a shopping list marked TREATS on the seat, at N. Scottsdale Rd and E. Camelback Rd

"Fine," I said. "Once upon a time, there lived a big, fluffy cat named Versace and he had run out of cat treats. Versace climbed into his little red car and drove to the store to get more. He had his shopping list on the seat beside him. It said TREATS, in very large letters. He was humming. The sun was shining. He stopped at the light on the corner, and when it turned green, he..."

Jeff and three cats all sit up in bed shocked and screaming as he reads the storybook

"AND HE GETS HIT BY A TRUCK!" yelled Rocky.

"AND HE JUST FILED BANKRUPTCY!" yelled Athena.

Versace's crown slid over one eye. "I beg your pardon?"

"Well," I said, "that is what happened next."

"So there was Versace," I went on, "sitting in the middle of the intersection in a very crumpled little red car. And before the dust had even settled, who should come rumbling up but the Repossessor, in his big tow truck, hooking up the wreck and hauling it away."

Versace, a crowned tabby, screams beside his crumpled red convertible on Main St as the Repossessor, a rhino in coveralls, pulls the wreck with a giant magnet and chain

What happens to my car loan if my car is totaled in bankruptcy?

"Not my car!" cried Versace. "Is he allowed to do that?"

If there's a loan on the car, the lender usually gets paid first out of the insurance money for the car. If the insurance doesn't cover the whole loan, how the rest is handled depends on your plan, so call your bankruptcy lawyer. If the car was paid off, the insurance money for it can be protected, up to the amount of Arizona's vehicle exemption.3

"Hmph," said Versace. "Go on."

"So Versace limped home with a very sore neck," I said, "and the next morning, he hired a good injury lawyer."

What happens if I get in a car accident during my Chapter 13?

"Does he have to tell anyone?" asked Athena.

Yes, right away. Tell your bankruptcy lawyer about the accident. Your bankruptcy papers will need to be updated to show the claim, because in Chapter 13 a new claim can become part of the bankruptcy.2 Depending on the timing and your plan, some or all of the money from it may have to go to the trustee for your creditors, after any exemptions.

What do I need to tell the bankruptcy trustee about my accident?

"What does the trustee need to know?" Athena asked.

Just the basics: when the accident happened, what kind of claim it is, and your injury lawyer's name and contact information. Your injury lawyer can fill the trustee in on the rest. Bankruptcy law requires you to cooperate with the trustee, and this is a big part of it.4 Ask your injury lawyer not to settle anything without talking to your bankruptcy lawyer first.

Rocky popped up from the foot of the bed. "Section 521! Duty to cooperate!"

"Thank you, Rocky. Lie down."

"Now," I said, "Versace's injury lawyer got to work. He sent letters. He gathered reports. And every few days, Versace's mailbox filled up with bills from the doctors who had fixed his neck."

A dream bubble shows Dr. Medical Bill, a snake doctor waving a $26,600 bill, and a mailbox stuffed with bills, while three cats lie in bed below

Can I wipe out my medical bills while my injury case is pending?

Athena's eyes went wide, and over the bed, a thought bubble filled with Dr. Medical Bill, waving a stack of invoices. "Can't the bankruptcy just make those go away?"

Not these ones. Medical bills from an accident after you file usually aren't part of your bankruptcy, so they won't be wiped out. And in Arizona, a hospital or other provider that treated your injuries can sometimes record a lien on your injury claim. The good news is that, in many cases, Arizona law keeps one-third of an injury settlement off-limits to those liens, though there are exceptions (for example, if you had no health insurance).5 Your injury lawyer and your bankruptcy lawyer should work together on how the providers get paid. Otherwise you could watch the recovery go to the trustee and still owe the doctors.

If your medical bills are from before you file, that's a happier story. They're ordinary debts, and bankruptcy can usually wipe out your personal responsibility to pay them, just like credit cards. A lien recorded before you file may still attach to the settlement, though, because bankruptcy doesn't automatically erase liens.

The thought bubble popped. Athena burrowed back under her blanket.

"But what if he hadn't filed yet?" asked Rocky. "What if the truck hit him first, and he filed bankruptcy after?"

"All right," I said. "Let's rewind the story."

Split panel: Jeff flips the storybook with a rewind icon while the cats watch; on the right, a crowned tabby, a red convertible and a rhino tow truck rewind through the scene

Do I have to list a car accident claim in bankruptcy if I haven't sued yet?

Yes. The moment you're hurt by someone else, you have a right to sue them, whether or not anyone has filed anything. Lawyers call that a "cause of action," and the law treats it as property, just like a car or a bank account. Everything you own on the day you file has to be listed, and that includes the claim.

"Section 541!" said Rocky. "Everything you own on the filing date!"6

Can I file bankruptcy while I have a pending lawsuit?

"What if Your Majesty had already sued the truck driver?" asked Versace. "Must one wait for it to end?"

No. You can file bankruptcy while your lawsuit is pending. But it can change who's in charge of the case, and the money from it may go first to your creditors. That's why the two lawyers need to talk to each other.

Who controls my personal injury case after I file Chapter 7?

"Then who is in charge of the lawsuit?" said Versace. "Me, I presume."

Rocky, an orange tabby, stands on the bed holding a book titled THE LAW, while Jeff thinks with a hand on his chin

Not in Chapter 7, Versace. A claim you had before you filed belongs to the bankruptcy estate, and the trustee steps into your shoes. Usually the trustee asks the court for permission to keep your injury lawyer working on the case, and the court approves the lawyer's fee and any settlement. The trustee then decides whether to settle the claim or give it back to you, which lawyers call "abandoning" it.7 Here too, the trustee needs your injury lawyer's name and contact information so the two can work together.

Versace sniffed. He does not like it when someone else is in charge.

Can the bankruptcy trustee take my personal injury settlement in Arizona?

"Will the trustee take all the money?" Athena whispered.

Not necessarily. The trustee can only take the part that no exemption protects. Exemptions are laws that let you keep certain things. Arizona doesn't have one general exemption for injury settlements, but a few specific ones can protect parts of some recoveries, like disability or accident insurance benefits, workers' compensation, and money for damage to property that was already protected. If part of a recovery isn't protected, the trustee uses it to pay creditors. If anything is left after the creditors are paid, it comes back to you.

"Actually," said Rocky, "Arizona opted out of the federal exemptions! So the federal personal injury exemption you see quoted online doesn't apply here!"8

"That's right, Rocky. Go to sleep."

Should I file bankruptcy before or after my car accident settlement?

"Then he should simply wait until it settles," said Versace. "Obviously."

That's not always the answer. Settling first doesn't take the claim out of your bankruptcy. It just turns the claim into money, and money in a bank account is easy to find and easy to spend. Filing first isn't automatically better either. The right timing depends on how big the claim is, how close it is to settling, what's exempt, and which chapter you're filing. This is a question to ask a bankruptcy lawyer before you do either one.

Does how my settlement is split up affect what I keep in bankruptcy?

"Does it matter what the money is for?" Athena asked.

It can. A settlement is often divided into pieces, such as medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and property damage, and some pieces may be protected when others aren't. So your injury lawyer and your bankruptcy lawyer should work together before anybody signs a settlement.

Rocky, an orange tabby, reads a book titled THE LAW on the bed beside Jeff and the other cats, as a REOPENED CASE shadow looms on the wall

What happens if I don't list my lawsuit in bankruptcy?

Versace's eyes narrowed. "And what if I simply... forgot to mention it?"

That's the scary part of the story. You sign your bankruptcy papers under penalty of perjury. Leave an asset off on purpose, and you can lose your discharge, which means your debts don't get wiped out.9 A claim that was never listed doesn't quietly become yours when the case closes. It stays part of the bankruptcy, and the trustee can reopen the case to go after it.10

It can cost you the lawsuit, too. If you tell the bankruptcy court you have no claims, the person you're suing can argue you shouldn't be allowed to pursue one. Lawyers call this "judicial estoppel."

Rocky sat straight up. "Ah Quin, Ninth Circuit, 2013. She almost lost her whole lawsuit, and fixing her bankruptcy papers is what got her another chance!"11

He's right. When a claim gets left off, going back quickly and fixing the bankruptcy papers can make a real difference. Better still, list it the first time.

"Now," I said, "back to the story. Versace was in his Chapter 13, his neck was getting better, and his injury lawyer and the trustee were working things out together. Everything was finally calm. Until one night..."

Does bankruptcy stop a lawsuit against me?

A seagull with a summons in its beak swooped past the window. It was the Seagull Server, carrying a lawsuit from one of Versace's old credit card companies.

"Oh no," whispered Athena. "Someone's suing him now?"

That's the other kind of lawsuit, and bankruptcy treats it very differently. When you file, the automatic stay stops most lawsuits against you over debts from before your bankruptcy.12 The Seagull Server can circle all he wants. He can't land.

A seagull in a top hat with a SUMMONS bounces off a glowing protective dome over the bedroom window while Jeff and the cats watch from the bed

Can a car accident judgment be discharged in bankruptcy if I was at fault?

"And what if Versace had caused the accident?" Athena asked, very sleepily now.

"Versace is a VERY safe driver," said Versace from his pillow.

Usually, a judgment from an ordinary accident that happened before you filed can be wiped out in bankruptcy, even if you were at fault. The big exceptions are injuries caused while driving drunk or impaired, and injuries caused on purpose, meaning willfully and maliciously.13

By then Athena was asleep under her blanket, and Versace's crown had slid over one ear. Rocky was still muttering, "Section 541... Ah Quin... thirty-three, eleven twenty-six..."

Jeff holds a finger to his lips as the cats sleep; a hooded cat with a feathered staff stands on the moonlit windowsill

Then there was a soft whoosh at the window, and Purr-da landed on the sill, his cape fluttering in the moonlight.

"Don't worry about King Versace," Purr-da said. "His bankruptcy case is still open, so the automatic stay is still protecting him from his old creditors. The Seagull Server can't touch him."

"Thank you, Purr-da," I whispered.

Purr-da glanced at the three sleeping cats and winked. "They didn't really need a lecture on the automatic stay. But they needed something to make them go to sleep."

We both laughed, quietly, so we wouldn't wake anyone.

And so King Versace got his treats, healed his neck, finished his plan, and lived happily ever after.

The end.

The moral of the story

If you have a claim against someone, whether it's a car accident, an injury or any other kind of lawsuit, tell your bankruptcy lawyer about it before you file. List it even if you haven't sued yet. If you get hurt during a Chapter 13, tell us right away so we can let the trustee know and connect the trustee with your injury lawyer. And if someone is suing you over old debts, bankruptcy may be exactly what stops it.

Had an accident? Download our accident checklist and bring it to your appointment.

Good night, cats. Good night, Seagull.

The End title card: the three cats asleep on the bed, while a seagull with a summons and a hooded cat with a staff appear at the window

Jeff, for Jeff Biddle Law (and the Bankruptcy Cats) 🐾

Pebble, an orange tabby cat, typing on a beige retro computer keyboard

Pebbles of Information

Rocky, the firm's research cat, dug up where all of this comes from.

  1. 1. 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1). The main Chapter 7 exception is an inheritance you become entitled to within 180 days after filing. 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(5)(A). ↑
  2. 2. 11 U.S.C. § 1306(a). ↑ ↑
  3. 3. Insurance or damages for exempt property are covered by A.R.S. § 33-1126(A)(5). The vehicle exemption is in A.R.S. § 33-1125(8). ↑
  4. 4. 11 U.S.C. § 521(a)(3) and (4) (duty to cooperate with the trustee and turn over information). ↑
  5. 5. A.R.S. § 33-931, including subsection (E)(1), which exempts one-third of a third-party judgment, settlement or award from the lien; A.R.S. § 33-932 (perfecting the lien). ↑
  6. 6. 11 U.S.C. § 541(a)(1). You have a duty to list your assets. 11 U.S.C. § 521(a)(1). The Statement of Financial Affairs also asks about lawsuits you're part of. Official Form 107. ↑
  7. 7. The trustee can employ special counsel with court approval. 11 U.S.C. § 327(e). The court approves the fee, 11 U.S.C. §§ 328 and 330, and any settlement, Fed. R. Bankr. P. 9019. Abandonment is covered by 11 U.S.C. § 554. ↑
  8. 8. Arizona has opted out of the federal exemptions. A.R.S. § 33-1133. Accident, health and disability insurance benefits, damages or insurance for exempt property, and damages for a wrongful taking of exempt property are covered by A.R.S. § 33-1126(A)(4), (5) and (8). Workers' compensation is exempt under A.R.S. § 23-1068(B). ↑
  9. 9. 11 U.S.C. § 727(a)(4) (false oath). ↑
  10. 10. 11 U.S.C. § 554(c) and (d); 11 U.S.C. § 350(b). ↑
  11. 11. Arizona is in the Ninth Circuit. In Ah Quin v. County of Kauai Dep't of Transp., 733 F.3d 267 (9th Cir. 2013), the plaintiff had reopened her bankruptcy and corrected her schedules, and the court held that the question was whether the omission was really inadvertent or mistaken. It vacated the summary judgment against her and sent the case back. ↑
  12. 12. 11 U.S.C. § 362(a)(1). ↑
  13. 13. 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(9) (death or personal injury caused by operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated) and § 523(a)(6) (willful and malicious injury). In Chapter 13, see 11 U.S.C. § 1328(a). ↑
Pebble, an orange tabby cat, smiling with both paws on a beige keyboard